|
Visual Attention Span (VAS)
Experienced readers rely upon processing words by sight. If a child has a
reduced ability to process words as a whole then they are forced to sound words out, which is their only way to make sense out of the print on
the page.
Many children struggle
with whole word processing because they have limited visual attention spans, which refers to the amount or bits (eg. letters) of information which
can be ‘grabbed’ or captured off the page with each fixation. The average span
of recognition for an experienced reader is 4-6 letter positions. We are able
to identify the shape of letters 10-12 letter positions away from fixation, but
not their identity. We are able to identify the length of a string of letters
13-14 letter positions away from fixation, but cannot decipher the shape or the
identity of the most distal letters. ie. those furthest away.
When reading the more
letters that we can capture with each fixation, the longer the words we can
read and the larger our sight word vocabulary. Whilst experienced readers have
a visual attention span of 4 to 6 letters many young children are only able to
capture one letter at a time in their working memory, which is generally going
to be a letter at the beginning of the word. Therefore the word ‘magnet’ would
be processed as ‘m_____’. Their limited attention span makes the child
insensitive to all the other letters in the word, it’s as if they are reading
down a cardboard tube, or even a straw. These same children will also be
insensitive to word length, as such the child may misguess the word as
‘measles’, ‘mistletoe’, ‘mother’ etc. In fact there are over 400 words that
would fit this visual pattern. Whole word processing is therefore inevitably
inaccurate in these children; nor can they rely on context because the same
problems of word recognition apply to all words in the sentence.
As a result the child may become a word guesser. To make matters worse if the child has poor
‘sounding out’ (phonemic processing) skills then they will be completely locked
out of the reading process.
A child with a visual attention span of 2 will usually select the two end letters ‘m____t’ when
reading. However there are still over 40 words (meat, mist, moat etc) that will
fit this pattern, and so word guessing is still not reliable.
When a child can
process 3 letters, m_g__t, there are only a few words that form a match in
memory (maggot, magnet, midget etc). Therefore their predictive guessing is
likely to be more accurate. As a result in order for a child to be a sight word
reader they must be able to capture three ‘bits’ of information consistently.
Visual attention span
improves with age and will improve with reading experience yet many children
starting school lack the capacity to accurately capture sufficient visual
information to support sight word reading. As such they are locked out of the
normal sight word reading processes. Studies have demonstrated that visual attention span correlates significantly with reading readiness in kindergarten[i]
and with reading in Grades 1 through 5[ii].
A visual attention
deficiency can create a detrimental guessing dependency which can be difficult
to break even once the child’s visual attention spans have improved. For example
a child with a visual attention span of 2 who is only able to process the end
letters of a word will often guess the mid-word letters and may become
insensitive to their sequence.
[i] Solan
HA, Mozlin R. The correlations of perceptual-motor maturation to readiness and
reading in kindergarten and the primary grades. Journal of the Optometric
Association 1986. 57, 28-35.
[ii] Solan
HA. A comparison of the influence of verbal successive and spatial simultaneous
factors on achieving readers in fourth and fifth grade: A multivariate
correlational study. Journal of Learning Disabilities 1987. Journal of Learning
Disabilities, 20, 237-242.
back to top
|